So often we (and I fully include myself in the ‘we’ here) criticize modern Charismatics/Pentecostals for their abuse of the gifts of the Spirit and compare them with the Corinthians. We rightly point to Paul’s correctives in 1Corinthians 12-14 and wonder how it is that Paul can be so misunderstood when he spoke so clearly. But am I alone in noticing that there were other* Corinthians (let’s call them the ’strong’) who also messed up quite a bit in other areas? They were the Corinthians who were confident in their knowledge and thought that they shouldn’t be blamed if others weren’t as confident as they were. These were the Corinthians who knew that there were no other gods so eating meat sacrificed to idols was fine and dandy, but this knowledge wasn’t shared by their ‘weak’ counterparts, and thus it posed some big problems (see 1Cor. 8-10).
More to the point, this knowledge wasn’t what it was cracked up to be since they missed the bigger picture and didn’t seem to understand what was really important (you know, stuff like unity in the body of Christ and whatnot). Do these ’strong’ Corinthians have modern analogues? They sure do! I submit that there’s any number of Christians who are reliant upon their own knowledge, but who alienate their allegedly weak brothers and sisters for not knowing as much as them. It’s great to be able to engage in rigorous exegesis and dismiss apparently ridiculous ideas and interpretations of Scripture, but if such knowledge and ability doesn’t promote unity, then what good is it? When Paul said that ‘knowledge puffs up’ did he mean that we should all be ignorant? Of course not! But he did mean that knowledge not grounded in love (which for Paul and the rest of the NT writers was evidenced in our actions toward God and each other) was useless. Remember, ‘love builds up,’ and this is precisely the same corrective he offered to those abusing the gifts. The major offense wasn’t as much in the disorder as it was in the disunity and selfish display of what God had given. The focus should have been on the building up of the body because ‘love builds up.’
B”H
*N.B. that for the sake of my point I’m referring to these Corinthians as ‘others’ when Paul doesn’t clearly make the distinction that I am making.